I live in Arizona, home of SB 1070, so this post will be hard. It's complicated. I grew up in New York City, granddaughter of immigrants, in the shadow of the Holocaust and under the upraised arm of the Statue of Liberty. I have paid taxes in Arizona for over 40 years without ever having the state government do anything I believed in. I am tired of being called names because I am against SB 1070.
Here are my thoughts. Like I said, it's complicated, especially if you live here.
First the obvious arguments you hear from everyone:
Arizona has almost half a million illegal immigrants, and they do overwhelm the schools, hospitals, and other public services.
They work for wages Americans won't work for, and they drive wages down.
Many do not speak English, and entire neighborhoods have become barrios.
Texas and California have built fences at their borders, and that funnels the illegals through the Arizona desert, in which many die.
Border towns have high crime rates, because of Mexican drug wars and human trafficking.
However, for years Arizona had English/Spanish versions of just about everything, and it was because of our Mexican heritage, of which we were really proud. Arizona has borrowed Mexican art and architecture liberally, and everyone here eats Mexican food. Most Arizonans have their lawns mowed, their houses built and remodeled, and their food prepared by Mexicans. We've admired their work ethic and taken advantages of their services. They have nannied our children, cleaned our houses, and picked our produce. Our zealous real estate community has sold them homes, and encouraged them to be part of our communities.
We have started Hispanic-focused marketing and advertising programs to get them to buy our products. They have been hailed as an up-and-coming "market segment." 30% of us (Arizonans) are them (Hispanics).
We never asked them if they were legal. As long as they were useful, we didn't really care. We assumed the best.
As a country, and as a state, we have looked the other way until recently. Then, suddenly, the economy re-set and here we are looking for people to blame. Why are there no manufacturing jobs and no construction jobs? Why, the Mexicans are doing them. Why do we have such large class sizes? It's those Mexicans. Why have crime rates soared? It's the Mexicans, of course. How about blaming Goldman Sachs, or the Fed? That's who most Americans are blaming. Only in Arizona have we turned against our neighbors.
Ironically, many illegals have already left Arizona. They know there's no work here. But the reason they don't go back to Mexico is that businesses in the US continue to hire them. Maybe not Arizona businesses, but all the other states that don't use E-Verify and don't have Sheriff Joe to make those daily sweeps and raids. They work in the chicken processing plants and the manufacturing plans in the midwest, the east, and the south. We're just the first stop for them.
As for the drug wars? Americans are the consumers of the drugs. Everybody wants marijuana from Mexico, and that's why it is such a big business. If we legalized it and taxed it, we could build more schools and hospitals and stop the violence at the border, which is about the illegal drugs, not the illegal immigrants. The illegal immigrants are just looking for work.
And don't get me started on Congress. This isn't Arizona's problem; it's Congress's problem. The Federal government is supposed to protect the borders. Those chickenshits are too scared to do anything on comprehensive immigration reform, so they've left it to the crazies in Arizona, who have their own agendas that are so deeply hidden that no one dares speak of them. But they can get sanitized as "law and order." That doesn't make any of it right, or in line with the American values with which I grew up (give me your tired, your poor…)
Which brings me to "enforcing the law." According to the law, if you are illegally in the US, it is only a civil crime, and shouldn't be a matter for this kind of enforcement. It is not a criminal offense to have overstayed your visa, unless you do something else, like blow up an SUV in Times Square.
But now we assume the worst, and that's what is really wrong with this law. Under this law, my housekeeper and friend Olivia, who has been with me for fifteen years and who is definitely legal, feels bad when she goes out in the street because she doesn't speak English. Since I met her, I've been teaching her English and she has been teaching me Spanish. We have a lot of fun with it, but I will tell you she has learned a lot more English than I have Spanish. Last Thursday, in our usual Spanglish conversation, I brought up the subject of this law, and suddenly we were both in each others' arms crying.
As I said, it's complicated. What do I conclude? That if you assume the worst of people you will get it. And if you assume the best, you will get that, too.
Posted via email from Not Really Stealthmode