"Health" Care

by francine Hardaway on February 7, 2008

This has been an interesting week. On Sunday night, my forner foster child. Josh, was beaten up with a baseball bat (after being held up at gunpoint and telling the marauders he had no money) on his way home from a SuperBowl party, and refused admission to the first hospital his sister tried to take him to. He was finally taken to John C. Lincoln Hospital, which has a Level 1 Trauma Center.

The injury was severe, although he will live. Every bone in his face was broken, his nose was smashed, his teeth were shattered, and his eye sockets all but destroyed. He will need a least three re constructive surgeries. Never mind the psychological consequences on a kid that already has lost both his parents and, as he aged out of the system, his foster parents.

And, of course, he is uninsured. He is 20, and thought he was immortal. He was also working on and off, sometimes at jobs that provided insurance, sometimes not. So he never registered for ACCCHS, Arizona’s version of Medicaid.

So he was thrown out of the hospital on Thursday, because the reconstructive surgeon can’t get to his case until Monday, and the hospital won’t keep him. He’s enrolled in ACCCHS now, because of course the hospital enrolled him immediately so they ccould get reimbursed for his care. But ACCCHS won’t allow him to stay in. So he goes “home” to sleep on the floor of the apartment his pregnant sister shares with another single mom with two kids.

Then comes Super Tuesday, with all the candidates ranting about the need for universal health care. But none of them saying it should be paid for by anyone but the insured or the employer.

This is an interesting conundrum to me. Let’s just say health care was the most important issue for me, which it is. Who should I vote for? Barack, who says there shouldn’t be a mandate to buy it? Hillary, who says it should be mandated but doesn’t tell us how Josh will pay for it? The Republicans, who want a “free market” solution?

Folks, as far as I can see, nothing would cover Josh, who works part time and intermittently while trying to go to school, or his sister Amanda, who keeps on losing jobs because of her skills deficiencies, or his brother Jerry, who is working for a company that does not offer health insurance and can’t get on ACCCHS because he’s a former felon.

Or the 47 million who “reject” health insurance that is offered to them because they can’t buy it and also buy gas.

Health insurance is not like automobile insurance. You can mandate automobile insurance, and if people can’t afford it, they can take the bus. You can’t just “mandate’ health insurance. Either health care is a right that society provides, or it is not. It’s interesting how the system now works. As the system stands, drug addicts, diabetics who don’t comply with their regimens, and smokers who give themselves COPD can get care, as long as they either can afford to pay for insurance (pay for their sins by buying insurance and shifting the cost of their care to the rest of us) or are dirt poor. In fact, the poorer they are, the better the care. And the worse people take care of themselves, the better the care they get. You can get a heart transplant more easily than you can get a colonoscopy.

It’s the working poor, the people trying to lift themselves out of poverty, who don’t get care. And trust me, one day that will include someone from your family.

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

James Farrar February 7, 2008 at 6:24 pm

what an ordeal! wishing Josh a speedy recovery. The health care situation is tough in America but also getting tougher in Europe. Funny how seemingly wealthy societies struggle to commit to providing social essentials such as health care and education.

GreenNetizen February 7, 2008 at 6:56 pm

Send this to Lou Dobbs and keith olbermann

molly February 7, 2008 at 7:02 pm

Francine, I saw your pictures on Flickr and wondered what had happened. I’m so sorry to hear about Josh’s plight … and equally horrified about healthcare in this country.

francine hardaway February 7, 2008 at 7:14 pm

I follow health care policy closely, and am also a person who deals with the working poor a lot. So I can’t see a workable solution, unless it’s a state run system like in Europe. And I don’t think Americans will tolerate that (yet).

francine hardaway February 7, 2008 at 7:15 pm

James, I feel the same way you do. Why can’t we provide education and health care? What’s a government for?

Judith February 7, 2008 at 7:50 pm

I don’t think we can vote for either Obama or Clinton based on their health care proposals. Neither are adequate, and as you say we won’t tolerate what is just, yet. Although the issue is central for me I have the make my decision on other issues. Strength to Josh and to you. Judith

Jeff Lapides February 7, 2008 at 9:10 pm

I thought you mind find the statistics I’ve put together on the so-call uninsured interesting. You can see them on my web site, http://www.politicalsunshine.com.

The oft-quoted number of over 40 million uninsured includes everybody who is uninsured. That includes wealthy people who self-insure, young adults who choose to take the risk, people temporarily in-between jobs, people eligible for government programs that are not aware of it AND the children of all of these people.

My own estimate is that the number of people who want but cannot obtain insurance could be half of the gross number reported. . . still a problem but not nearly as big.

My new site goes to the source of these statistics and others and presents them in an easy to read format and provides some interpretation without taking political sides.

Regards,

Jeff Lapides

Jeff Lapides February 7, 2008 at 9:13 pm

I thought you mind find the statistics I’ve put together on the so-call uninsured interesting. You can see them on my web site, http://www.politicalsunshine.com.

The oft-quoted number of over 40 million uninsured includes everybody who is uninsured. That includes wealthy people who self-insure, young adults who choose to take the risk, people temporarily in-between jobs, people eligible for government programs that are not aware of it AND the children of all of these people.

My own estimate is that the number of people who want but cannot obtain insurance could be half of the gross number reported. . . still a problem but not nearly as big.

My new site goes to the source of these statistics and others and presents them in an easy to read format and provides some interpretation without taking political sides.

Regards,

Jeff Lapides

francine hardaway February 7, 2008 at 9:16 pm

Thanks, Jeff; that’s really cool. I agree that all those people are out there. I just want people who seek health care to be able to get it. I know it’s not a simple issue. And it’s good to know where the numbers are.

Deborah February 27, 2008 at 7:46 pm

I wish him a speedy recovery. Although Josh represents a large number of young people without health care there is another hidden number that I believe takes a toll on innovation in this country. Let me ask you a question. If Steve Jobs or David Packard had to worry about health coverage for their families, would they ever have stepped a foot into the garage in the first place? Way too many bright, innovative people are working inside of companies because of their absolute need for health care benefits. Our assumption that health care should be linked to employment with a company is simply outdated, ineffective and broken. Sole practitioners, aspiring entreprenurs, artists, writers, journalists, technology geniuses, find it very difficult to buy insurance policies on their own. The astounding rate of rejection by health insurance companies for individuals not attached to group plans offers very few solutions for the Creatives, the entrepreneurs– How many more years do we have to talk about this problem before we fix it? As Americans, we should all be outraged. Why don’t we start a grassroots movement around the concept of our healthcare? Relying upon the government and politicians to solve this crisis will take forever.

francine hardaway February 27, 2008 at 8:19 pm

I’m in total agreement with you, Deborah, as I have been an entrepreneur all my life.

Lily March 13, 2008 at 12:31 pm

What a terrible story! And that sort of thing happens over and over. It’s not much help, but I do know of a great prescription discount card. It’s at http://www.rxdrugcard.com. Low membership fee. Drug prices posted on the website to check before you enroll.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: